The journey of research and surgery is often marked by unexpected turns and obstacles. In the process of scientific inquiry, where paths often lead to unexpected destinations, the idea of Amor Fati—love of one’s fate—is an ancient principle, rooted in the Stoic philosophy, that offers insights for modern researchers facing the unpredictable nature of their work. Embracing Amor Fati in this context means more than persevering through challenges. It means actively loving the path of discovery, with all its setbacks and successes and transforming these setbacks into sources of strength and wisdom.

The Historical Roots of Amor Fati

The concept of Amor Fati is not explicitly mentioned by the early Stoics; however, it is deeply embedded in the Stoic approach to life’s inevitable challenges. Among its many contributions to the Western philosophical tradition, the concept of Amor Fati stands out for its profound acceptance of life’s unpredictability. This love of fate is not about passive resignation but an active, joyful acceptance of all that life offers.

Friedrich Nietzsche, though not a Stoic himself, famously encapsulated this sentiment when he said, “My formula for greatness in a human being is amor fati: that one wants nothing to be different, not forward, not backward, not in all eternity. Not merely bear what is necessary, still less conceal it… but love it.” Nietzsche’s interpretation echoes the Stoic belief in embracing life’s challenges with enthusiasm rather than endurance.

Stoic Philosophers on the Virtue of Embracing Fate

Marcus Aurelius and his Meditations provide a timeless testament to the Stoic life, with reflections that have to do with the nature of the universe and the virtues of patience, understanding, and acceptance. He wrote , “Accept whatever comes to you woven in the pattern of your destiny, for what could more aptly fit your needs?” His thoughts on fate highlight the importance of seeing the order and beauty in the unfolding of life’s events.

Seneca, whose letters and essays offer rich insights into Stoic thought, discussed the serenity that comes from aligning oneself with nature and accepting the course of events. His writings underscore the belief that true wisdom lies in understanding what is within our control and what is not, and in finding contentment in both.

Epictetus, a former slave who became a prominent Stoic teacher, emphasized the freedom that comes from accepting one’s fate. His Discourses argue that external events are beyond our control, but we can control our responses to them, thereby finding peace.

Deepening the Connection: Amor Fati in the Researcher’s Journey

Peer review is an important part of the modern scientific method. Your scientific peers take a look at work and make a judgement. Should it be published in this journal? Is it important enough for it to make the program of a scientific meeting? Is the work proposed in a grant impactful to public health and is the work rigorous enough so that it will provide valid results? Sometimes the peers think your proposal or your paper is groundbreaking. Sometimes they don’t. One of the first grants that I submitted was to a surgical society. The topic was about how obesity influences the physiologic response to injury. I thought that this was an important and timely topic, even 25 years ago. While the public health impact was clear to the reviewers, the science I proposed was not clear nor rigorous enough to warrant funding. When I got the rejection letter, my immediate reaction was disappointment and then anger. “I put a ton of work into this! Don’t they see that?” I have learned through other rejections to let this emotional response pass. With a little time, I can read the critiques and learn from them. Controlling my emotions and looking on with some objectivity helped. When I took the time to read the grant again, it hit me. I really didn’t like the topic. I needed to shift my focus to something that I cared more deeply about than the one I had chosen even though what I wanted to do might be a harder and longer path to funding. I accepted my fate and I was able to transform the this potential source of discouragement into a learning opportunity.

I have another confession to make. Overnight call in the hospital is a challenge. It is physically and psychologically demanding to stay up all night taking care of patients and not knowing how busy you will be or what you face. I used to get angry thinking about it. “Why do I need to stay up all night?” “Why can’t someone else do it?” “Why do we have a system like this?” Once I realized that I spent so much energy railing against call – something that I could not change – I understood how much time I was wasting. My focus and attention would be better served somewhere else. So, I changed my thinking around taking overnight call. Know I view it as a chance to serve the community, as a way to help other humans, and as a way to be a teacher and mentor to younger surgeons. By reframing the concept of overnight call – I accepted my fate.

Practical Tips on Cultivating Amor Fati in Daily Research Activities

1. Reflect Daily: Start or end your day with a few minutes of reflection on what went well and what didn’t. Embrace both with gratitude.
2. Reframe Setbacks: When faced with a setback, ask yourself, “What can this teach me?” This reframe can transform challenges into opportunities for growth.
3. Celebrate the Small Wins: Research is a marathon, not a sprint. Celebrating small milestones can help maintain perspective and motivation.
4. Connect with Colleagues: Share your experiences with peers. Often, they can offer insights or perspectives that can help you see the value in your research journey’s ups and downs.
5. Embrace Uncertainty: Learn to find comfort in not knowing. Each question leads to new discoveries, and each discovery opens the door to more questions.

The Broader Implications of Amor Fati for the Research Community

Adopting Amor Fati has implications beyond individual resilience. It can foster a research culture that values process over results, encourages risk-taking, and supports creative thinking. That is the point of what we do here on this blog, on the podcast (that will come!) and in the day to day work we do. We delve into this notion of Amor Fati and seek to understand how it and other Stoic principles can reshape the ethos of individuals, groups, and research institutions. Ultimately, promoting a more collaborative, innovative, and resilient scientific community is more fulfilling and productive for all involved.

---